How to answer a plan review comment
The reviewer is looking for the cloud, the sheet, and the section.
A plan review comment is a request to change the documents or to show where they already comply. It is not an invitation to a general essay. The response that clears is short. It names the comment number, the sheet that changed, and the code section in the edition the city adopted.
The 2021 IBC says why the drawings have to move with the letter. Section 107.4 says work is installed in accordance with the approved construction documents, and any change during construction that does not comply with those documents is resubmitted as an amended set. You can read that section in Chapter 1. A letter that promises a future revision, with no revised sheet in the package, is not an amended set.
Write the response in the order of the comments, not in the order you felt them. For each one:
- Restate the comment in a few words so the reviewer can see you read it.
- Say what changed: "Sheet A1.2, door 104, now swings in the direction of egress. Occupant load of the room is 62."
- Cite the adopted section, not a section from the other edition. Door swing for 50 or more occupants is Section 1010.1.2.1 in the 2021 IBC, which the door swing guide walks through.
- If you disagree, show the drawing that already complies and quote the exception you are using. Disagreement without a sheet reference goes back to the bottom of the pile.
Cloud the change or mark it the way that department asks. The model code does not specify clouds. The intake checklist does. If you do not know the local mark-up rule, ask before you resubmit. Sending a clean set with no mark of what moved makes the reviewer read the whole set again, and the next letter will say so.
The mistake is a response that argues Section 508, or travel distance, or accessibility, while the floor plan still shows the condition the comment described. Fix the drawing first. The letter only points at the fix. The common comments guide is a list of what those comments tend to be. It is not the response.
Before you resubmit, upload the revised set and run a free scan. Catch the next mismatch before the reviewer does.
This is advisory. It is not a determination by the authority having jurisdiction. Confirm the adopted edition and local amendments before you change a drawing.