The energy report is not in the file
The reviewer cannot check a calculation that is still in someone's inbox.
A large share of energy comments are not about a failed wall. They are about a missing report. The drawings say "see COMcheck." The COMcheck is not in the PDF. Intake or the energy reviewer stops there.
The commercial energy code is the International Energy Conservation Code, which the IBC points at from its energy chapter. The documentation path — what has to be in the construction documents, and commissioning where the energy code requires it — is the subject of the energy compliance guide. That guide is written around IECC Sections C103 and C408. Confirm those section numbers in the energy code the city adopted before you cite them. Envelope values, when you get that far, are the thermal envelope guide. The model building code, for the chapter that sends you to the energy code, is at ICC.
What the file needs at intake, before anyone debates a U-factor:
- The compliance path, named on the code sheet: prescriptive or simulated performance. "Meets energy code" is not a path.
- The report itself, bookmarked in the same PDF as the drawings, with the project address matching the application.
- The climate zone printed on the report and on the drawings. A report run in the wrong zone is a different comment, and it looks like a passed report until someone checks the zone against the site.
- The edition of the energy code. It follows the city's adoption, which you confirm from the jurisdictions page and the ordinance. A 2021 report in a city on an older energy code is the wrong book, same as a wrong IBC edition.
The mistake is emailing the report to the architect and never placing it in the submittal set. If the reviewer cannot open it from the file you uploaded, it was not submitted. Lighting and mechanical compliance are separate sections of the same problem. The lighting guide and the mechanical efficiency guide are those sheets. Attach them or show them on the drawings. Do not leave them as a promise.
Upload the set, including the energy report, and run a free scan. A missing report is a completeness problem. A wrong climate zone is a design problem. They should not arrive in the same letter if you open the PDF once before you send it.
This is advisory. It is not a determination by the authority having jurisdiction. Confirm the adopted energy code and local amendments before you change a drawing.